https://twitter.com/SelectaVision/statu ... 68/photo/1
Not exactly a good look IMO using interlaced DVD footage.
Moderators: General Help, Kanzenshuu Staff
Kunzait_83 wrote:No matter what twisted pretzel logic you contort yourself into to try and convince yourself otherwise, Raditz landing on Earth is the middle of the fucking story. Zero context, zero setup. Its in NO way meant to be seen as a "beginning point" for ANYTHING other than the next story arc. It flows precisely and fluidly from where things left off in the aftermath of the 23rd Budokai and mostly hits the ground running from there without really stopping to look back. You're plopping someone into the middle of a book starting at chapter 195 out of 519 for absolutely no good goddamn reason, with very minimal opportunity to look back at much needed context and character/story growth.
If you're talking the older shows, no. Not until Toei actually remasters the series & gets a good studio to do it for them & that won't ever come because Toei's not actually interested in doing that. It took them a decade too long to remaster the movies & the TV specials & that was after FUNi's attempts to do so. The shows, minus GT, are just too long & they wanna do things on the cheap, which never mix. To put things in perspective, Star Trek: TNG took over $2 million to get remastered in HD, which involved redone SVFX, new CGI to replace elements they didn't have anymore, as well as scanning in & cleaning up the footage & that's for 178 episodes. As well as remixing the audio into 7.1. DBZ has 123 more episodes than that, then you add on DB's episodes. It'd cost probably close to that to give the shows a proper remaster, including GT. It'd be worth it, but is that an investment Toei's willing to make? Unfortunately, no, it's not.PremiumSalt wrote: ↑Wed Oct 30, 2019 8:53 pm And there it is.
Ugh. Can't we have anything nice? Is this franchise just cursed to never have a good release?
You're inflating how difficult this is to a ridiculous degree. Dragon Ball, Z, and GT don't need any recreated effects, the materials don't exist to remix it into anything beyond the original mono or stereo sound, and Toei's materials for Dragon Ball/Z/GT are actually in very good condition, and all very easily accessible in their vaults.Scsigs wrote: ↑Wed Oct 30, 2019 10:51 pmIf you're talking the older shows, no. Not until Toei actually remasters the series & gets a good studio to do it for them & that won't ever come because Toei's not actually interested in doing that. It took them a decade too long to remaster the movies & the TV specials & that was after FUNi's attempts to do so. The shows, minus GT, are just too long & they wanna do things on the cheap, which never mix. To put things in perspective, Star Trek: TNG took over $2 million to get remastered in HD, which involved redone SVFX, new CGI to replace elements they didn't have anymore, as well as scanning in & cleaning up the footage & that's for 178 episodes. As well as remixing the audio into 7.1. DBZ has 123 more episodes than that, then you add on DB's episodes. It'd cost probably close to that to give the shows a proper remaster, including GT. It'd be worth it, but is that an investment Toei's willing to make? Unfortunately, no, it's not.PremiumSalt wrote: ↑Wed Oct 30, 2019 8:53 pm And there it is.
Ugh. Can't we have anything nice? Is this franchise just cursed to never have a good release?
True, it probably wouldn't be $2 million for the entirety of DB, pre-Kai, to be remastered in HD properly, but it'd still be a lot for 508 episodes of a cartoon on film to be properly remastered to clean up the film & present the episodes in a good master. Star Trek: TNG also suffered from not having a master film stock that they could scan in for each episode, so they had to dig out all of the film reels in their archives & re-edit them from the ground up, though they couldn't find EVERY bit of it, since there's a few times small portions of a few episodes weren't available in the film stock, so they had to splice in color-corrected VHS footage from the DVDs, which they did pretty well in doing. So, it's not exactly a 1:1 comparison, but remastering ANYTHING isn't easy or cheap. Hell, Square Enix had to rebuild Kingdom Hearts 1 from the ground to remaster it for the HD collections they did, same with several of the 3D Final Fantasy games, so there's different levels of remastering something depending on what it is (&, I know video games aren't the same thing as film, but that was just something that came to my mind).Robo4900 wrote: ↑Thu Oct 31, 2019 12:23 pm You're inflating how difficult this is to a ridiculous degree. Dragon Ball, Z, and GT don't need any recreated effects, the materials don't exist to remix it into anything beyond the original mono or stereo sound, and Toei's materials for Dragon Ball/Z/GT are actually in very good condition, and all very easily accessible in their vaults.
It would still be expensive to remaster all 508 episodes, but unlike TNG, they wouldn't literally be rebuilding the entire show from its base elements, basically doing an entire post-production process on an entire 7-season TV show again. All Toei have to do is scan the film in and clean it up properly. Which is expensive and time-consuming, and Toei probably don't see any real benefit to doing it for the Japanese market (which means they won't do it), but... Seriously, man, the TNG comparison is just utterly ridiculous.
... But yes, Toei are not doing a HD remaster any time soon. The best we will likely ever have is the DBoxes, as ultimately crappy as they are.
I have a theory about that actually. In the DVD screenshots you'll notice very heavy combing that isn't present in most other official releases (a few spots in the Dragon Boxes aside). I suspect Selecta Vision wanted a new master from Toei that didn't have this issue.Dragon Ball Ireland wrote: ↑Thu Oct 31, 2019 3:47 pm So it was an upscale after all?
What was the point of Selecta Vision trying to get better masters from TOEI if they weren't going to take this remaster seriously?
What I don't understand is why they did a true HD remaster for Mazinger Z, but not for any of their other series.kei17 wrote: ↑Fri Nov 01, 2019 12:31 am From What I know, they started this fuckery when they released Galaxy Express 999 on Blu-ray in 2014, and they at least made an excuse about why it ended up just an upscale; They said the original film masters were missing and they had no choice but to upscale the digibeta masters produced for the DVD release. I do think it's total bullshit, though. Probably it still sold well thanks to the popularity of the series, and then they thought that consumers wouldn't care any difference between true HD remaster and upscale when it comes to 16mm footage and it's a waste of money to bother to rescan 16mm film. It's the label of "HD" what actually sells. From then on, they always do the same with any other non-35mm TV series, now even with no single excuse to justify not to rescan film masters!
Toei is a faithless greedy miser. They make Funimation look somewhat faithful.
That's because Mazinger Z was produced in 35mm. Toei Animation switched to 16mm film for TV anime productions in the middle of the '70s, so the most part of Great Mazinger and all of Grendizer were produced in 16mm.Mosaic wrote: ↑Fri Nov 01, 2019 12:44 pmWhat I don't understand is why they did a true HD remaster for Mazinger Z, but not for any of their other series.kei17 wrote: ↑Fri Nov 01, 2019 12:31 am From What I know, they started this fuckery when they released Galaxy Express 999 on Blu-ray in 2014, and they at least made an excuse about why it ended up just an upscale; They said the original film masters were missing and they had no choice but to upscale the digibeta masters produced for the DVD release. I do think it's total bullshit, though. Probably it still sold well thanks to the popularity of the series, and then they thought that consumers wouldn't care any difference between true HD remaster and upscale when it comes to 16mm footage and it's a waste of money to bother to rescan 16mm film. It's the label of "HD" what actually sells. From then on, they always do the same with any other non-35mm TV series, now even with no single excuse to justify not to rescan film masters!
Toei is a faithless greedy miser. They make Funimation look somewhat faithful.
You're pretty greedy yourself, wouldn't you say?
As I recall, you've claimed to have obtained everything he has, so if it really bothers you, and you weren't just trying to make a show of yourself, you'd do something about it, rather than just take cheap shots at an insightful member of this community. And don't give me some crap about "people won't use my materials so I'm done with it" like you've done whenever anyone else has confronted you on this in previous threads. You took Kei's materials and sold them to people like Enigmo, for your own ends. That's how this started, and that's how it progressed for multiple years. You're in this for yourself, your own greed, so... Pot, meet kettle.
It's very easy to look at a time you never lived through and think it was great, or even the same for a time you did live through, a long time ago. Nostalgia is a powerful thing.AnimeMaakuo wrote: ↑Fri Nov 01, 2019 1:52 pm Regarding Toei Animation, nothing has, or ever will change that. They're more interested in making money from suckers than doing something for the fans who made them a fortune.
"We choose to go to the Moon in this decade and do the other things, not because they are easy, but because they are hard!"
- John F. Kennedy
Back then, people had some kind of sense of mission. They wanted to achieve the impossible, dream the unimaginable, and leave a legacy behind for the next generation that would follow in their footsteps. In the electronics industry, companies like JBL, Pioneer, Sansui, Marantz, Onkyo, McIntosh, etc., would build the most expensive equipment (even if it was a financial risk) that would withstand the test of time. They would include detailed literature on how their amplifiers and speakers were measured, designed, assembled, packed, etc. People took pride in their work and were proud to stand behind their product. But those days are over...
Nowadays business’ are competing for the cheapest made product with the flashiest packaging to fool people with. Their stance is, “we made the cheapest product possible and made the most money ... and the average folk are okay with it.” It’s true that most fans of the show simply don’t care about demanding the very best. They will continue to buy garbage and support garbage because that’s what they’re told to accept. Sad, isn’t it?
I’ve decided to accept our fate with this franchise and move on with my life.